Essential Medical Billing & Consulting
Free tool · No email required

What does your billing actually cost you?

Most practices compare a billing company’s percentage against a biller’s salary. That is not the comparison. Salary is roughly two-thirds of what an in-house biller costs. Put your own numbers in and see the whole figure.

Every figure here is an example, including the percentages. They are not a quote from anyone, and rates vary from practice to practice.

Your numbers

$

What actually lands in the bank each month, not what you bill.

In-house billing

Count part-time honestly — a front-desk person doing billing half the day is 0.5.

$
%

Employer taxes, workers’ comp, insurance, paid leave. Commonly 18–28% on top of salary.

$
$

What an hour of your time is worth, not what you pay yourself.

Outsourced billing

% of collections

Published rates generally fall between 4% and 10%, most often 5–8%. This is an example figure, not a quote. Enter whatever rate you have actually been offered — ours and everyone else’s vary by practice.

$

Coding, credentialing, patient statements, eligibility, prior authorisation — whatever the quote excludes.

The comparison

In-house, per year—
Outsourced, per year—
—
—

In-house, as % of collections—
Outsourced, as % of collections—

These are example figures, not a quote. Billing rates vary from client to client with claim volume, claim values, specialty mix and how much of the work is included — ours included. This also compares cost only: it says nothing about whether either option collects more of what you are owed, and that difference is usually larger than the cost difference.

What this calculator assumes

Every assumption is visible and editable above. Nothing is hidden in the maths, and there is no thumb on the scale — the same formula runs whichever answer comes out ahead.

Every percentage here is an example

The rates on this page are illustrative defaults so the calculator has something to work with. They are not a price list and not a quote — not from us and not from anyone else. What a billing company charges varies from client to client with claim volume, average claim value, specialty mix, and how much of the work the fee actually covers. Two quotes at the same percentage can mean very different amounts of work.

Our own pricing works the same way: it depends on the practice, and we quote it after looking at your numbers rather than publishing a single rate that would be wrong for most people.

What it deliberately leaves out

These are real costs, and excluding them means the in-house figure shown above is conservative — the true number is usually higher:

When in-house genuinely wins

It happens, and the calculator will show it. Percentage-of-collections pricing tracks revenue, not workload — so a practice with high collections and a low claim count pays a lot for relatively little work. If you submit a modest number of high-value claims, run the numbers and then ask any billing company for a flat monthly fee instead. If they will not quote one, that tells you something.

The other case: your billing already works. If claims go out within a day or two, denials are worked rather than resubmitted, and your A/R over 90 days is under control, the honest advice is to leave it alone.

Check it against reality

Numbers on a page aren’t the same as your numbers.

Send us your A/R aging report and we will tell you what is actually collectible, what is close to timing out, and whether the problem is cost at all. If your billing is working, we will say so.

Request a free A/R review
PHONE(631) 766-0446
EMAILinfo@essentialmbandc.com
PILOT30 days, parallel processing
COVERAGEAll 50 states
Scroll to Top